Snoopy Double Trouble – Which Book to Keep?

You can’t keep them all! There comes a time in every collector’s life when they need to make a decision. Which to keep and which to sell? Sometimes it’s easy to determine which collectible is the more desirable piece to have in your collection. Other times, you’re left in a Snoopy double trouble situation.

I was recently at an antique store and couldn’t pass up this trio of near mint condition Peanuts Weekly Reader books. At $4 each, I figured it would be worth giving them a new home, either in my collection or passing them on to another collector through my shop. Luckily, I found their duplicates right when I got home and decided to share the decision process through the video above.

How to Choose

Usually with books, I first look at the edition. A first edition in very good condition might beat out a mint condition sixteenth edition. However, these are Peanuts books were published by Weekly Reader and don’t list any edition numbers. Instead, I start with the outer cosmetics of each book. Then, I move inside to see if there is any messy writing, colored in comic panels, major stains or other problems. Problems like aging paper, called foxing, I usually ignore as it’s part of the natural aging process. If the decision isn’t obvious after looking at the edition number and the cosmetic looks, then I just have to go with my gut.

Have a collecting topic you’d like me to discuss? Drop me an email at


Our online shop is filled with great Peanuts books for your Snoopy room shelves. Subscribe to our newsletter to find out what’s new in the shop and stay tuned for when these three books go up for sale.

Join the insider’s club! Support on Patreon. Patreon is a virtual tip jar to show your appreciation for the content on our site. For just a dollar, you’ll be the first to know what’s coming up for the week, plus go behind-the-scenes and find out first about special and exclusive offers. Give a little more and you’ll be eligible for special gifts, discounts, chat sessions, and more! Your support encourages me to keep creating new stories, photos and video for Thank you!

Peanuts Finds from eBay

Uncover Vintage Peanuts treasures at eBay and help support Thank you! Learn more...

Send this to a friend